Betty Magnolia and Other Little Girl Magnolia Varieties Compared

Betty Magnolia and Other Little Girl Magnolia Varieties Compared

Betty is the bigger, bolder choice among the Little Girl magnolias. It reaches 10 to 15 feet, while a sibling like Ann stays near 8 to 10 feet. Pick Betty if you have the room and want a show. Pick Ann or another sibling if the space is tight. The choice matters, because a magnolia in the wrong spot either outgrows it in a few years or never flowers as well as it should.

Betty Magnolia nursery tree
Betty Magnolia Nursery-grown Betty Magnolia, shipped to your door. Sizes from 1 Gallon Shrub. From $80.55.
Shop Now →

In this article, we'll go through how the series fits together, the winter checks on size and hardiness, the April bloom and its soft scent, and the care that keeps Betty flowering year after year. We follow the seasons, so you can act on each step when its time comes.

Betty Magnolia and the Little Girl Series

The Little Girl magnolias come from one breeding program, so they look alike at first glance. Start by learning what they share and where they split.

The Little Girl series consists of eight hybrid cultivars, each crossed from Magnolia liliiflora (native to China) and Magnolia stellata (native to Japan). The program at the National Arboretum in Washington, D.C. aimed to produce compact, hardy magnolias with reliable bloom and cold tolerance.

All eight cultivars share common traits: they're deciduous shrubs suitable for USDA zones 4 through 8, and they remain small enough for residential landscapes. Beyond that, they diverge in bloom color, exact size, and growth habit. Unlike the much larger saucer and tulip magnolias, they never outgrow a small yard.

The series includes Betty, Ann, Jane, Judy, Pinkie, Randy, Ricki, and Susan. Betty is one of the earlier releases and remains among the most widely available in nurseries.

While all eight cultivars share the same parent species and general hardiness range, they differ in bloom presentation and mature size.

Magnolia 'Ann' produces deep red or reddish-purple flowers and tends toward a more compact form than some of its siblings. It is frequently compared to Betty and is one of the most commonly confused pairings in this series.

Magnolia 'Jane' features purple flowers and is another cultivar often seen alongside Betty in garden centers. Like Ann, Jane is compact and widely available.

Magnolia 'Susan' produces flowers that are typically pink or rose-tinted and blooms later in the spring season.

Magnolia 'Judy', 'Pinkie', 'Randy', and 'Ricki' round out the remaining cultivars, each with its own distinct bloom color and growth tendency. Check with your local nursery or extension service for their specific sizes and bloom characteristics in your region, as these details can vary based on growing conditions and climate.

Winter: Check Betty's Size and Hardiness

Winter is the time to plan, because bare ground shows you exactly how much room you have. Measure your spot before you shop.

Plan for a plant that grows 10 to 15 feet high and 8 to 12 feet wide. Betty is hardy through a zone 4 winter, and it grows in zones 4 through 8. Ann, its closest sibling, stays at 8 to 10 feet high and wide, and that gap of a few feet decides many purchases. We often see customers set Betty three feet from a wall because the tag said "small." Give it the full width. Our guide on how big Betty Magnolia gets covers the numbers in more detail.

This table compares the main cultivars on color, size and standout traits.

Cultivar Bloom Color Mature Height Mature Width Best Feature
Betty Purplish pink 10-15 ft 8-12 ft Large flowers with 12-18 tepals
Ann Deep red throughout 8-10 ft 8-10 ft Uniformly deep red blooms and a dense habit
Jane Purple Compact Compact Purple tone and wide availability
Susan Pink to rose Compact Compact Latest bloom timing and a softer pink color
Judy, Pinkie, Randy, Ricki Varies (pink, red, magenta tones) Compact to small Compact to small Variety of color options and specialty cultivars

Note: Specific mature heights and widths for cultivars other than Betty may vary by region and growing conditions. Check with your local extension service or nursery for details on the variety you're considering.

Early Spring: Enjoy Betty's Bloom

Betty flowers early, and the show is short. Plan to be outside when it happens.

In Minnesota, Betty blooms in mid-April, and your date will shift earlier or later with your climate. The flowers are large and purplish pink with 12 to 18 tepals.

Lean in and you will catch a light, sweet scent. Our page on Betty's fragrance explains how strong to expect it.

In our rows, the first bees work the open flowers on the earliest warm afternoons. If a hard freeze is forecast while the flowers are open, drape a sheet over the plant at dusk and remove it in the morning.

Customers usually ask us how to tell Betty from Ann, so here is what to look for.

Betty and Ann are the pair most often confused at nurseries. Both are hardy to zone 4 and both stay in a small-garden range, though Ann is the smaller of the two. The main distinction lies in bloom color and habit.

Look at color first. Betty's flowers read as purplish pink, while Ann's are typically deeper red throughout. Some growers report that Ann holds a slightly tighter, more columnar habit than Betty, though this is subtle and depends on growing conditions and pruning.

Set blooms from both side by side and Ann looks more uniformly red, while Betty looks softer. If you love a strong red statement, choose Ann. If you prefer a softer purplish pink, choose Betty.

Mid-Spring: Choose the Spot and Soil for Betty

Once the flowers fade, the ground is warm enough to plant. Pick the site before you dig.

Set Betty in full sun to part shade, and give it the most sun you can for the heaviest flowering. It grows in moist, well-drained, organically rich soil and tolerates clay if drainage is adequate. Aim for soil that is acid or neutral, because very alkaline conditions can cause chlorosis. Once established, Betty has low to moderate drought tolerance.

Many guides tell you to dig a huge hole and fill it with rich amendments. We don't. Backfill with the native soil, because a rich pocket inside heavy clay turns into a bowl that holds water. Our guide to the best soil for Betty Magnolia shows how to test drainage first.

Through the Growing Season: Water, Feed and Prune

Care is light, but timing matters. Follow these steps from spring into fall.

Water a newly planted Betty deeply whenever the top few inches of soil dry out, because its drought tolerance is only low to moderate. Spread mulch over the root zone, and keep it a few inches back from the trunk.

Once established, they need moderate water and benefit from a light annual feeding in early spring with a balanced or acid-forming fertilizer. Pruning is minimal. If shaping is needed, do it immediately after flowering since buds for next year set soon after bloom.

Skip the late-winter pruning you would give most trees. We don't follow that advice here, because next year's flower buds form soon after bloom and a winter cut removes them. Minimal pruning is required, so most years you will only trim crossing or damaged branches.

For detailed care instructions specific to Betty Magnolia, see our complete care guide.

Fall: Weigh Betty Against Ann and Susan

Fall is when nurseries have their best selection, and you can still plant before the ground freezes. Compare your options before you buy.

Betty Magnolia

Here is how Betty stacks up on its own merits.

Pros:

  • Mid-April bloom gives an early start to the season
  • Large purplish pink flowers with 12 to 18 tepals add visual interest
  • Tolerates zones 4 through 8, including cold climates
  • Minimal pruning required
  • Widely available at nurseries

Cons:

  • Larger (10 to 15 feet tall) than some compact Little Girl cultivars
  • Prefers acid or neutral soil and can develop chlorosis in alkaline soil
  • Low to moderate drought tolerance requires regular water until established
  • Purplish pink blooms may be less dramatic than solid deep-red or vivid pink options

Ann Magnolia

Ann is the closest rival, so weigh it next.

Pros:

  • Deeper, more uniform red blooms
  • Tends toward a very compact form, ideal for tight spaces
  • Cold hardy, with the same zone range as Betty
  • Lower maintenance due to dense growth habit

Cons:

  • Earlier bloom timing means higher frost risk in cold climates
  • Less widely available than Betty in some regions

Susan Magnolia

Susan is the choice for a softer color and a later show.

Pros:

  • Later bloom timing offers maximum frost protection
  • Pink-to-rose color is softer and distinctive
  • Very compact size suits small gardens

Cons:

  • Less common and may be harder to source
  • Smallest of the series, limiting landscape presence

Which Little Girl Magnolia Should You Plant?

Match the plant to your space and your taste in color. These short checklists make the call.

Choose Betty Magnolia if:

  • You want large purplish pink flowers that open around mid-April in cold climates
  • You prefer a plant that reaches 10 to 15 feet and creates a visible focal point
  • You live in zones 4 through 8 and want a proven performer
  • You want easy availability and nursery selection

Choose Ann Magnolia if:

  • You prefer deep, solid red blooms
  • You have a very small space and need maximum compactness
  • You accept earlier bloom timing and late-frost risk as a trade-off for darker color

Choose Susan or other specialized cultivars if:

  • You want the absolute latest bloom timing for maximum frost protection
  • You prefer pink or rose tones over red or purple
  • You're willing to hunt for specialty nurseries or mail-order sources
  • You're building a collection and want variety within the Little Girl series

Quick Reference: Little Girl Magnolia Comparison

Use this table as a last check before you buy.

Feature Betty Ann Jane Susan
USDA Zones 4-8 4-8 4-8 4-8
Mature Height 10-15 ft 8-10 ft Compact Compact
Bloom Color Purplish pink Deep red Purple Pink to rose
Bloom Timing Mid-April in Minnesota Early to mid-spring Mid-spring Late spring
Availability Widely available Readily available Readily available Less common
Best For Large flowers, focal-point spaces Compact spaces, deep red color Purple preference, moderate spaces Latest bloom, soft pink color

Sizes, growth rates, and specific characteristics for all cultivars other than Betty are general guidelines and may vary by region, growing conditions, and local nursery stock. Always confirm cultivar-specific traits with your nursery or local extension service before purchasing.

Betty Magnolia, Season by Season

Measure your space in winter, enjoy the mid-April flowers, plant in acid or neutral soil with good drainage, and prune only right after bloom. Choose Betty for a 10-to-15-foot focal point with large purplish pink flowers, and choose Ann or Susan when space or color points elsewhere.

Betty Magnolia nursery tree

Betty Magnolia

Nursery-grown Betty Magnolia in sizes from 1 Gallon Shrub, shipped to your door.

From $80.55

Shop Now →

Before a plant leaves us, our growers check the roots, the branch structure and the flower buds, and we confirm that the label matches the cultivar. We grow on our own farms and sell top-quality trees and shrubs, so the Betty you plant is the one you chose.